Re: Alien Abduction Cases
ok - here goes (K-C - I am late, but I am a man of my word):
ok. so the likelihood that the Earth has been visited by intelligent aliens is pretty much nil.
the universe is so big, and we are so small in it - that the odds of an alien race finding us, let alone going through the trouble to traverse the vast distances to actually get here, are ridiculous.
here's a great animation showing just the absolute insignificant size of our
PLANET in comparison to other heavenly bodies (let alone the distances between them - which is by many, many, many, many orders of magnitudes greater):
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HEheh1BH34Q[/youtube]
And - if they did come here, why would they hide from everyone and just suck up a few hicks and cows and then sexually experiment on them? Not that we have any ability to actually infer what their motives may be, as we have no real concept of what they would be like...
Why do we assume they have come here in ships? How come all the sightings have them in ships? the likelihood that they would come here in ships is such a human abstract...which goes to show that the "sightings" are more likely than not human constructs
I have been a lifelong reader of science fiction - so i am one who genuinely would like to know (like KRex). To me it seems very likely that somewhere in the universe there is other intelligent life - the universe is just so big - it seems very plausible that intelligent life evolved somewhere else. The idea that it hasn't and we are unique, given the vast...truly vast...amount of planets, stars and galaxies just doesn't seem reasonable...to
ME. However, using the same logic, it is extremely unlikely that they have been clandestinely visiting our planet.
Two really good examples of what possible encounters with alien "life" are:
Sphere, by Michael Crichton
Contact, by Carl Sagan
Sphere deals with the fact that if we were to encounter alien life, the idea that it would in any way, shape or form be something that we could even recognize as an intelligent "life" is pretty much zero. And this book really drives home my point of putting "life" in "quotes"...what we comprehend intelligence, heck - LIFE, to be...are 100% based upon what WE KNOW about life here on Earth. The likelihood that "life" that developed somewhere else in the galaxy could be something that we could recognize, let alone comprehend, is remote.
And Sagan's book, which makes the assumption that we could comprehend the alien intelligence, because it chose to display itself in a human-type fashion, basically says that due to the vast distances of the universe, the idea that they would travel in "ships' is absurd. It would most likely start with some form of long distance "communication", and any "travel" would have to involve some completely unknown and unknowable form of "teleportation" or wormhole-like travel.
So as someone who truly "wants to believe" - I will never let my critical judgement be replaced by someone's claim of "eyewitness accounts", the least reliable form of evidence in almost every situation imaginable. (see the fascinating story of Picking Cotton as this applies in the criminal justice system.
http://www.pickingcottonbook.com/home.htm.
And of course, as for the "video evidence" - they are ridiculous. Every single one has been thoroughly debunked by actual experts and scientists - and even if they haven't been (which isn't true) - and one of them actually represented something we could not explain, the idea that it would be an alien intelligence is literally the least likely of all possible explanations.
As Sagan put it in his amazing book "The Demon Haunted World" - a true tome for the Skeptics (one which I assume KRex, as self professed "skeptic", probably thinks is 100% bullshit..love ya K-Dawg ):
so show me the "ship"...not some bullshit video or transcripts of what someone claims to have seen. Jesus -give me a break. I read The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy... why shouldn't we believe that is true if we take the "eyewitness account" of those idiots in NH from 50 years ago? Both are just as likely to be true to me.
If they are here - is it really that hard to prove to someone? Why? Are we all in on the conspiracy to NOT believe? I know the Washington Monument exists...and I can buy a $400 plane ticket and prove it.
As the Human Torch would say "FLAME ON!"