h3dg3h0g wrote:
Luc wrote:
Phil O is right.
He really is. And he also pointed out at FHA that visibility of higher frets is an issue with the way some of us hold our Sticks.
With linear inlays, visibility is greatly enhanced. With a more diagonal approach, the inlays are visible from the side, like dots on the top of a guitar neck (at least on the hardwood and bamboo models. The more vertical the instrument's position, the better, as all the strings intersect the marker in exactly the same way, no matter how far they are from the center line of the board. Each string/fret position is clearly indicated, instantly.
As with any choice, there's a trade-off at work here. More vertical positioning makes it so much easier to play left hand chords, especially the most important chord of all, the basic major triad.
This video demonstrates both the enhanced visibility of linear inlays, and the enhanced playability of more vertical positioning.
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5TZi0qKzKCM[/youtube]
Specific comments about positioning bregin at 10:50, but I'd suggest you watch the whole video for context.Just my perspective (oy, pun intended), but I wouldn't trade the enhanced chord ergonomics a more vertical position gives me for anything, unless there was some big leap in technique possibilities offered. Looking at the board is sometimes very important, and when I do need to look, the vertical inlays give me all the information I need very clearly and quickly.
As indicated earlier in this thread, I love the sensation of playing with my eyes closed. Great topic, Jonathan.